Shelf Reports

DA-ActionSA feud threatens Gauteng’s economic future

By Tiffany Morgan
·
Share:
DA-ActionSA feud threatens Gauteng's economic future - da-actionsa feud
Both sides hold valid grievances, from the GNU to Tshwane’s collapse.

Helen Zille and Herman Mashaba have been feuding since 2019. Ron Weissenberg argues that Gauteng can’t afford this conflict any longer.

Both sides hold valid grievances, from the GNU to Tshwane’s collapse. Weissenberg says they don’t need to merge or even like each other. They just need a shared platform for clean local governance. Residents without water can’t wait.

The Looters and the Lawgivers

South Africa’s political scene is unique. There’s a clear divide between the Looters and the Lawgivers. The Lawgivers, ActionSA, ACDP, FF+, DA, and IFP, support the rule of law and constitutional democracy.

When Lawgivers join Looters, toxic coalitions form. But even worse is when personal egos become a battleground. The prolonged feud between Herman Mashaba (ActionSA) and Helen Zille (DA) is one such battle. The casualty isn’t just Johannesburg’s future, but South Africa’s economic stability.

A History of Conflict

Mashaba resigned as Johannesburg mayor and left the DA in October 2019 after Zille’s election as Federal Council chairperson. He framed his exit as a principled stand. In hindsight, it highlights a flaw in South African politics: bruised egos spawning toxic factions instead of consensus-building.

By creating ActionSA, Mashaba didn’t unite a broader coalition. The party capitalized on voter frustration but cannibalized the middle-class opposition vote. Instead of a unified front against the ANC’s erosion, the DA and ActionSA have spent years in recrimination, dividing constituencies needing competent alternatives.

Read Also: Asia Leads Global Nuclear Build-out with 73% Share

The bad blood goes beyond 2019 and ActionSA’s rise in the 2021 local elections. The DA’s 2024 decision to join the Government of National Unity (GNU) was seen as a betrayal by ActionSA. ActionSA’s move to collapse the DA-led Tshwane coalition left the DA distrustful of Mashaba’s reliability.

The Prize of Unity

A unified DA-ActionSA coalition after the 2026 elections could govern Johannesburg, Tshwane, Ekurhuleni, Emfuleni, and Mogale City, along with Midvaal already held by the DA.

A Path Forward

Repairing the divide doesn’t require ActionSA to capitulate or the DA to compromise its core identity. Zille and the DA must acknowledge Mashaba’s success in addressing marginalized communities, while Mashaba must accept that splintering the opposition weakened their collective power. They do not need to merge, nor do they need to like each other. However, they must establish a joint platform for clean, accountable local government.

Voters’ Role in Coalition Politics

Voters must clearly signal that their support is contingent on shared ideology and cooperation among political parties. Residents whose taps have run dry and whose businesses are failing cannot afford another term of political grandstanding.

Sign up for your early morning brew of the BizNews Insider to keep you up to speed with the content that matters. The newsletter will land in your inbox every morning on weekdays. Register here. Support South Africa’s bastion of independent journalism, offering balanced insights on investments, business, and the political economy, by joining BizNews Premium. Register here.If you prefer WhatsApp for updates, sign up to the BizNews channel here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *