
Seven of South Africa’s eight major cities lack a clear majority party, leading to intense coalition negotiations. The ANC, now holding just 30% national support, has signaled it views the DA as a “last resort” partner. This stance raises concerns about the future of the Government of National Unity (GNU) if the ANC excludes the DA from metro governments.
Key ANC figures, including President Cyril Ramaphosa and Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana, are notably absent from negotiations, attending events in Silicon Valley and London. Meanwhile, ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba has demanded the DA drop its mayoral candidates in Johannesburg and Tshwane as a condition for coalition talks, complicating efforts to form stable city governments.
The ANC’s indecision echoes a historic editorial
In 1983, The Star newspaper, then a major publication with a circulation of 250,000, refused to endorse either side in a referendum on P.W. Botha’s tricameral constitution. Its editor, Harvey Tyson, advised readers to abstain, earning criticism from colleagues. One staffer famously quipped, “The editor’s indecision is final,” a phrase that now resonates with the ANC’s current stance on coalition talks.
The ANC’s reluctance to commit to the DA may hinge on deals it can secure elsewhere. However, the absence of key moderates like Ramaphosa and Godongwana has left hardliners such as Fikile Mbalula and Paul Mashatile in charge of negotiations. This dynamic could shape the outcome of coalition talks and the future of the GNU.
The DA’s strong performance in recent elections, particularly in Gauteng, has positioned it as a critical player. However, Ramaphosa’s reported frustration with DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis over coalition outreach suggests personal tensions may influence political decisions. If the ANC excludes the DA from metro governments, the DA’s participation in the GNU could become untenable, potentially leading to economic instability.
Amid these negotiations, ActionSA’s Herman Mashaba has emerged as a wildcard. While his voters favor a DA-ActionSA alliance, Mashaba’s demands for the DA to drop its mayoral candidates in Johannesburg and Tshwane have stalled talks. This raises questions about Mashaba’s intentions and whether he is setting impossible conditions to justify a coalition with the ANC.
Notably absent from these discussions is any concrete plan to address the corruption and mismanagement plaguing South Africa’s cities. The focus on political maneuvering overshadows the urgent need for competent governance and infrastructure repair. Hill-Lewis, who has maintained a measured approach, has emphasized the importance of fixing cities, but his strategy remains unclear.
Read Also: Asia Leads Global Nuclear Build-out with 73% Share
The absence of ANC moderates like President Cyril Ramaphosa and Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has left hardliners in control of coalition talks. Their focus on Silicon Valley and London contrasts with the urgent issues in South Africa’s cities, such as Johannesburg’s closed swimming pools and dry taps.
David Makhura, a key figure in the GNU negotiations, is also abroad, studying in London. Meanwhile, Fikile Mbalula, Paul Mashatile, and Panyaza Lesufi are directing operations at home, raising concerns about their approach to governance.
The recent election in Emfuleni, where the DA won 34 wards from the ANC, highlights voter dissatisfaction with the ANC’s governance. This result shows the need to address corruption and infrastructure failures in coalition talks.
However, his strategy remains unclear, and the lack of concrete plans to address corruption and mismanagement in coalition talks is a significant concern.
Citizen Sentiment and Unaddressed Issues in Coalition Talks
Recent events in Emfuleni municipality highlight public frustration with infrastructure failures. For over two years, residents have faced collapsed sewage and water systems, with raw sewage flooding streets and homes. This situation reflects broader concerns about governance and service delivery, which coalition negotiations have yet to address.
Despite numerous initiatives announced during his presidency, including commissions, task forces, and war rooms, tangible improvements remain elusive. The focus on political maneuvering overshadows critical issues like corruption, mismanagement, and basic service provision. Municipal payrolls, bloated by unaffordable wage hikes, further strain resources, leaving essential services like rubbish collection neglected.
The absence of credible plans to appoint competent officials or tackle systemic corruption shows the gap between political promises and citizen needs. As parties jostle for power, the lack of attention to these fundamental issues risks deepening public disillusionment and exacerbating urban decay.
